Alexia Anders and her boyfriend Jay Romero are sitting in her bedroom, having a conversation about a recent church sermon. Jay is also her youth pastor, and is pleased with Alexia's interest in the topic. They talk about the fact they haven't had sex yet. They wonder if they should, and worry that it might be wrong. After discussing, they agree that they don't need to rush: they should start slowly. They begin with innocent kisses, but find themselves wanting more Jay pulls down Alexia's panties and they decide to try a little missionary sex, convincing themselves that its okay as long as they're using a condom. However, after trying that for a bit, they remove the condom and keep fucking... all the way to a vaginal creampie. A soon-to-be-married couple (Ebony Goddess Mystique and Codey Steele) are cleaning up after a rehearsal dinner with the help of Codey's best man, Mickey Mod. Though Ebony and Codey shower praises onto Mickey for his assistance, he seems to have something on his mind. He finally opens up and confesses that he wants Ebony for himself, claiming that from the moment he saw her, he was in love with her. This infuriates Codey, and the two men nearly come to blows, before Ebony steps in and separates them. She sits both men down on the couch and places herself between them, trying to figure out which man to choose. Ebony then comes up with a brilliant idea: why don't they both fuck her, and whoever does it the best wins her heart? When multiple creampies are in order, everyone's a winner!